Women and Money
I just did a post saying ‘Men and Money’ so here is a post on Women and Money. Assuming that the Man is the main provider and the wife is the secondary (financial) provider, what are the things she should do to know how much is the husband earning? Is it enough? Are they living within their means?
Ask him!
Life is however, not so simple. Many men themselves do not know whether they are earning enough. So they may not give you the right answer. Also if a man has inherited a lot of money he may assume his standard of living to be his birth right. So many of these people become ASSET rich, but cash flow poor. Imagine having a house in Bandra (ok Defence Colony in Delhi) worth Rs. 3 crores, but not having the cash flow to pay maintenance charges! It is not uncommon.
As a wife you should:
a) ask for a fixed amount of money for household expenses – and keep increasing the asking. In case you can, start saving a portion of that – you are asking the money to see if he can afford the cash flow, not to really spend it.
b) tell him that each kid costs……Rs. and therefore as a family you SHOULD do a SIP in a couple of mutual funds to the extent of say Rs. 35,000 p.m.
c)….ditto….Rs. 50,000 p.m. for retirement
when you put these kind of loads on his cash flow and he is able to do it, fine.
However, he can give you excuses like:
a) My CA says we need to use the money in the business.
b) I need to repay the bank, and the bank is objecting to the investing before the loan is repaid
c) I get a better return on my own business
d) Equity markets are too risky – and mutual funds are risky.
Learn to find out how much is true and how much is false…….after all wives should be good at that!
If you are just a girl friend and want to know how much is he earning, file an RTI…and get a copy of his Income Tax Return copy from the department!! LOL
Ashish
Can’t they refuse to release the IT return – as done with Sonia?
Atul
Hi Subra,
I agree that women should play equal role in financial planning.My observation is that women are not inclined to this part, even the working ones. But yes, women understand the value of money more than men.
Cheers
Atul
umesh ikhe
Great Post Subra !!
I am seeing it is wonderfully happening in my case and in my near friend circle equally well.
For sure woman are better money manager ( at least in our cases !!)
regards
Umesh Ikhe
suhas
I second Umesh’s & Atul’s Comment
Lakshmi
good advice to all the wives and girl friends……
T K VANI
hi
It is not enough if she asks for money and he gives.She should also question his source. to quote a life example one of my friend’s hubby kept giving her money and they lived life in high style eventually to learn that he had accumalated a debt of 80 lakhs (he had played in derivatives trading).he was a Manger in a five star hotel and owned a gym.Now he has lost everything and lives and works in Ethiopia incognitio to avoid the loan sharks. Children,wife and parents are living a nightmare.
T K VANI
All this while I kept thinking IT Returns are personal.Is it not true? then how come sonia Gandhi refused to divulge details quoting it is her personal matter?
pravin
IT returns are personal information.But it is not personal for people in public life.people who handle public funds have an obligation to declare their personal information so that they can be seen as not stealing those public funds.it is a tranparent governance issue ^^
BombayBoy
Aren’t IT returns of a pvt individual well, private? I’m not talking about those in public/govt offices. We are talking about regular Amar, Akbar, Anthony’s here.
Can you really get it through RTI?
Rudy
GFs filing RTI… LOL… gud one subra…
Dominic
GFs filing RTIā¦ She should be a GF of a politician. LOL.
praveen shukla
as per my knowledge nobody can ask for individuals IT return unless and until required to be produced in the court or required by law enforcing authorities. So no LOL girlfriends