Talking to parents about money!
I meet all kinds of kids – and it is worth seeing their attitude towards money and their parents….
Some kids think that their parents owe them a living! Some kids hate spending their parent’s money – even a farthing!
This is not about their attitude, it is about their ability to communicate with their parents about money. Recently I met one kid who has got admission in an institute where the total expenses are about Rs. 3 million for the whole course – it is a 2 year course.
This boy wanted to know the following:
1. Can my dad really afford this?
2. How much of an impact will it make on his retirement corpus? (father is in service, and will retire in 7 years time)
3. Should I repay this like a loan or is it a gift?
4. If I take a loan will I be able to repay it….and is that a good option?
5. How do I decide whether to do this course at all – personally I do not have so much money to invest/spend?
I was really surprised (actually sad) that this boy needed to ask me (a rank outsider) all these questions! His parents should be answering these questions…..well er…the kid should have already known these answers, right?
For example I knew my Dad’s salary, savings, investments….etc. right in my 12th class. At that stage I could influence his portfolio, now I fashion it!
Then I realised that not all parents are so open about their money arrangement. Not sure if it is a matter of wanting to be secretive or what – but it is nice to let the kids know what they can afford and what they cannot. I knew what my dad could afford – if I had got admission in IIT or MBBS he could have paid the fees without batting an eyelid. I am not sure if I would have asked him to pay capitation fee – but I am sure he could have afforded it. Like a typical Tam brahm family it would have been easy to find Rs. 100,000 (remember 1980 figures!) for an Ivy League education, but would have found it difficult to find Rs. 20 for a movie (LOL)…
Parents should either do a full disclosure or at least tell the kids:
– I have about Rs. 3 crores + a house, and a nice job.
– I will happily pay Rs. 30 L for your education as a gift and am willing to give you a Rs. 20L interest free loan in case you need it, but not a penny more.
– I am not too keen to sign a bank guarantee in excess of Rs. 20 L (instead of the int free loan mentioned above)
– Remember I need to do all this for your sister also :-). Both my kids share my love equally, but education expenses will be on a NEED basis, subject to the same rules.
– I will pay your medical insurance, vehicle insurance, etc. till you are comfortable in your cash flow (once you start earning)
– If you earn anything up to Rs. 10k a month, it will be all yours – and you can fund all your fun activities…once you earn a sensible amount, I want you to repay the loans that you owe me (edu expenses above Rs. 30L)
– of course, once your salary exceeds Rs. 7 lakhs, I expect you to pay rent, pay for food, and pay for OUR vacations too 🙂
Ashish
Indeed its the need Subra Sir.
People just don’t want to discuss money at all.
T S Ashok
Still our people have many sentiments. These things may happen only in next to next generation..
aniket
nice artical sir
Chetan Trivedi
Now a days this is required to do by parents